Sunday, August 10, 2025
Nordic Monitor
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
    • Give us a tip!
  • About Us
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
    • Give us a tip!
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Nordic Monitor
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
  • About Us

Among 17 judges in European rights court, Turkish jurist alone claims Erdogan critics receive a fair trial in Turkey

September 29, 2023
A A
Turkish judge at Europe’s top human rights court defends government’s false arguments during proceedings

Judge Saadet Yüksel

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Levent Kenez /Stockholm

In a landmark decision with potentially far-reaching implications, the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) ruled on Tuesday that the conviction of Yüksel Yalçınkaya, a teacher in Turkey, on terrorism charges, which included using a mobile phone app and having an account at a specific bank, was unlawful. The decision could have significant consequences for thousands of individuals facing similar charges in Turkey.

The ECtHR found that Turkey had violated three key articles of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR): Article 6, guaranteeing the right to a fair trial; Article 7, prohibiting punishment without law; and Article 11, protecting freedom of assembly and association.

On March 21, 2017 a Kayseri court had sentenced Yalçınkaya, who is still incarcerated, to more than six years in prison on conviction of terrorist organization membership based on his alleged use of the ByLock messaging app and having an account at Bank Asya. In 2020 he applied to the ECtHR, claiming his rights had been violated.

Yalçınkaya was alleged by the prosecutors to be affiliated with the Gülen movement, a group opposing President Recep Tayyip Erdogan. The Turkish government declared the Gülen movement a terrorist organization, but the declaration received no international support.

Turkish ECtHR Judge Saadet Yüksel, who consistently stands apart from the majority in human rights cases involving Turkey, continued her pattern of expressing differing opinions in that case, unsurprisingly, siding with the Turkish government.

Yüksel was the sole judge among 17 who argued that Article 6, which ensures a fair trial, had not been violated and voted in favor of Turkey in this case.

In her partly dissenting, partly concurring opinion in the verdict, Yüksel claims that the majority’s evaluation of the domestic court rulings does not align with established ECtHR case law. She argues that their focus on specific deficiencies within the domestic proceedings, without considering the case as a whole, is contrary to ECtHR jurisprudence. Yüksel also emphasizes the crucial role of raw data in the applicant’s case and questions the majority’s emphasis on the failure to disclose it. She suggests that determining data disclosure should remain within the jurisdiction of national courts, rather than the ECtHR.

Yüksel’s opinion being nearly identical to one expressed by the Turkish minister of justice after the verdict was announced is noteworthy.

During Yalçınkaya’s hearing absentia in January, Yüksel had asked his lawyers a question in line with the Turkish government’s arguments about an encrypted messaging app that the Supreme Court of Appeals ruled did not constitute sufficient evidence of a crime. Human rights defenders and lawyers described this as a scandal, demanding that Yüksel withdraw from the case.

As part of the ruling Turkey was ordered to pay Yalçınkaya 15,000 euros to cover costs and expenses.

The ECtHR criticized Turkey’s use of the encrypted messaging app ByLock as evidence, citing it as overly broad and arbitrary, lacking the necessary safeguards for a fair trial. Furthermore, the court highlighted significant procedural deficiencies in Yalçınkaya’s trial, including the denial of access to evidence and the absence of an independent examination of data.

The court also noted that Turkish authorities had used Yalçınkaya’s legitimate membership in a labor union as evidence against him, thereby violating his right to freedom of assembly and association under Article 11 of the ECHR. This ruling holds broader implications for similar cases in Turkey, emphasizing the necessity for legal proceedings to align with European human rights standards

Following Yüksel’s appointment to the top court, human rights observers expressed concern about her impartiality given the close relations between her and Turkey’s ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP). Not only was her brother Cüneyt a senior AKP lawmaker and former deputy chairman, but Yüksel herself was affiliated with Islamist foundations supported by the Erdogan government. She was also an assistant to and student of the late Burhan Kuzu, a chief aide and leading propagandist of President Erdogan. Nordic Monitor previously published a report on Yüksel’s strong ties to the government. Her brother returned to parliament in the general election held in May.

Yüksel and former ECtHR President Róbert Ragnar Spanó were at the center of harsh criticism in September 2020. Spanó was the first ECtHR president to pay an official visit to Turkey, the government of which is a party to more than 16 percent of the cases before the Strasbourg court. Spanó and Yüksel met with President Erdogan behind closed doors at his presidential palace. 

Those who expected Spanó to give a strong message to top officials that Turkey must implement European court judgments and respect the rule of law were disappointed. Spanó made courtesy calls and received an honorary doctorate from Istanbul University, which has fired scores of academics in a massive crackdown since 2016, at a ceremony that students and journalists were not allowed to attend, at Spanó’s request. Spanó also went to Yüksel’s hometown of Mardin, a city in southeastern Turkey

French daily Le Monde claimed that Yüksel and Spanó are close friends, implying that their relationship is more emotional than professional.

ShareTweet
Previous Post

Detained mobster confessed to exploiting Turkey’s lenient money laundering laws

Next Post

Huge surge in the number of Russian, Iranian owned companies in Turkey amid sanctions

Levent Kenez

Levent Kenez

[email protected]

Next Post
Huge surge in the number of Russian, Iranian owned companies in Turkey amid sanctions

Huge surge in the number of Russian, Iranian owned companies in Turkey amid sanctions

Erdogan whistleblower and key witness faces extradition from Greece amid fears of torture and silencing

Erdogan whistleblower and key witness faces extradition from Greece amid fears of torture and silencing

August 8, 2025
US judge blocks Turkey’s attempt to weaponize American courts in political witch hunt

US judge blocks Turkey’s attempt to weaponize American courts in political witch hunt

August 7, 2025
Hizb ut-Tahrir, backed by Turkish jihadist groups, challenges President Erdogan

Hizb ut-Tahrir, backed by Turkish jihadist groups, challenges President Erdogan

August 6, 2025
Turkey’s spy agency views children as sources of intelligence for national security

Turkey’s spy agency views children as sources of intelligence for national security

August 5, 2025
Turkey’s main opposition CHP is in cahoots with President Erdogan and his allies

Erdoğan uses Turkish intelligence agency MIT to silence critics, threaten foreign nations

August 4, 2025
Erdogan gov’t pushes people to use ‘Next’ app as Turkey moves toward China-style digital control

Erdogan gov’t pushes people to use ‘Next’ app as Turkey moves toward China-style digital control

August 1, 2025
Turkey’s top appeals court rejects Greek nationals’ claim on Ottoman-era property

Turkey’s top appeals court rejects Greek nationals’ claim on Ottoman-era property

July 31, 2025
Turkey open to previously owned Eurofighter purchase amid urgent air force needs

Turkey needs stronger air force to counter Israel and Greece simultaneously, pro-gov’t think tank warns

July 30, 2025
Turkey forgives millions in debt for countries buying its weapons

Turkey forgives millions in debt for countries buying its weapons

July 29, 2025
Notorious ISIS commander wanted by INTERPOL received treatment in a Turkish state hospital, official document shows

Turkey refused to seek extradition of ISIS fugitives behind deadliest terror attack

July 28, 2025

Nordic Monitor

Nordic Monitor is a news web site and tracking site that is run by the Stockholm-based Nordic Research and Monitoring Network. It covers religious, ideological and ethnic extremist movements and radical groups, with a special focus on Turkey.

Tags

al-Qaeda Andrei Karlov China coup Cyprus Diyanet Egypt espionage Germany Greece Gülen Movement Hakan Fidan Hamas Hulusi Akar Ibrahim Kalın IHH Iran IRGC Quds Force ISIL ISIS Isis al-qaida Israel Libya Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu Milli İstihbarat Teşkilatı MIT Muslim Brotherhood NATO President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan Profiling Qatar Recep Tayyip Erdoğan Russia SADAT spying Spying Activities Suleyman Soylu Sweden Syria Torture Turkey Turkish Intelligence Agency Turkish intelligence agency MIT Ukraine United States

Recent News

Erdogan whistleblower and key witness faces extradition from Greece amid fears of torture and silencing

Erdogan whistleblower and key witness faces extradition from Greece amid fears of torture and silencing

August 8, 2025
US judge blocks Turkey’s attempt to weaponize American courts in political witch hunt

US judge blocks Turkey’s attempt to weaponize American courts in political witch hunt

August 7, 2025
Hizb ut-Tahrir, backed by Turkish jihadist groups, challenges President Erdogan

Hizb ut-Tahrir, backed by Turkish jihadist groups, challenges President Erdogan

August 6, 2025

Copyright © Nordic Research and Monitoring Network All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
    • Give us a tip!
  • About Us

Copyright © Nordic Research and Monitoring Network All rights reserved.