Sunday, June 22, 2025
Nordic Monitor
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
    • Give us a tip!
  • About Us
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
    • Give us a tip!
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Nordic Monitor
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
  • About Us

UN Human Rights Committee rejects Erdoğan regime’s main arguments on terrorism cases linked to Gülen movement

November 22, 2022
A A
Erdoğan gov’t has not been receptive to UN visit on arbitrary detentions in Turkey for years

Palais des Nations, Geneva. (UN photo)

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Levent Kenez/Stockholm 

The United Nations Human Rights Committee on November 15 released its decision on an application made by a teacher in Turkey who was detained and arrested over alleged terrorist links in 2018. Calling for the immediate release of the teacher, the committee’s decision will set a precedent for tens of thousands of terror suspects and people convicted and imprisoned on similar charges in the country.

Teacher Mukadder Alakuş was detained on September 4, 2018 on allegations that she was a member of the faith-based Gülen movement. Alakuş was not given food, water or medication for her daylong detention. 

She was arrested the next day and sent to a prison in Eskişehir. In December 2018 a local court in Manisa sentenced Akkuş to seven years, six months in prison for membership in a terrorist organization. The court cited the fact that the suspect deposited money in the now-closed Bank Asya, downloaded the ByLock encrypted communication application and participated in a peaceful demonstration organized to protest the government as grounds for membership in the terrorist organization.

In an undated photo, Mukadder Alakuş in prison with her son, who came to visit her.

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan first branded the Gülen movement as a terrorist organization in the aftermath of the December 2013 corruption investigations that incriminated him, his family members and his business and political associates in an Iran sanctions-busting scheme. He accused Fethullah Gülen, who inspires the movement, of initiating the graft probes, an accusation that Gülen denied. 

The Turkish government also accuses the Gülen movement of orchestrating a controversial coup attempt on July 15, 2016. The movement, however, strongly denies any involvement.

The Turkish government accepted such activities as having an account at the Gülen-affiliated Bank Asya, holding an administrative position at a Gülen movement-linked institution, subscribing to the group’s publications, being a member of a trade union or other institution linked to the Gülen movement and using the encrypted messaging application ByLock as benchmarks for identifying and arresting tens of thousands of followers of the Gülen movement on charges of membership in a terrorist organization.

The UN Human Rights Committee, in its consideration of the merits, recalled that the notion of “arbitrariness” must be interpreted broadly to include elements of inappropriateness, injustice, lack of predictability and due process of law as well as elements of reasonableness, necessity and proportionality. 

The committee noted that the Turkish government has only provided a partial copy of the court hearing of December 28, 2018, without providing any further documentation, such as an arrest warrant or detention order, regarding the evidence against Alakuş that would justify her detention.

“In these circumstances, the Committee considers that the State party has not demonstrated that the author’s detention met the criteria of reasonableness and necessity. The Committee therefore finds that the [author’s] detention amounted to a violation of her rights under article 9 (1) of the Covenant,” the committee decision reads. 

 

The committee also said it cannot conclude that Akkuş’s alleged use of the ByLock application and Bank Asya account amounted to sufficiently clear and predictable criminal offenses at the time the acts took place. Many defendants with the same status as Alakuş used this determination of the UN committee in their defense during their trials but were unable to convince the courts.

The committee announced yet another decision that will set a precedent in terrorism trials in Turkey, considering that “as a matter of principle, the mere use or download of a means of encrypted communication or bank account cannot indicate, in itself, evidence of membership of an illegal armed organization, unless supported by other evidence, such as conversation records.” 

The committee noted Alakuş’s allegations that she was unable to adequately prepare her defense; that she was denied access to the entire case file; that she was not permitted to call and cross-examine witnesses; that she was not allowed to attend her trial in person despite her request dated December 14, 2018; that the conduct of proceedings online and her displaced dentures impeded her from correctly expressing herself. The committee’s decision also said the Turkish government has not provided sufficient explanations or documentary evidence, such as full transcripts of the judicial proceedings, in order to substantiate its refutations of Alakuş’s allegations regarding her right to a fair trial.

The committee also noted that the defendant’s persistent request to be physically present in the courtroom and to make her defense was denied. Alakuş had to follow the hearings via a video conference system called SEGBİS, a  violation of the right to a fair trial according to the committee.

One of the issues that the experts who evaluated the decision of the committee drew the most attention to is that the committee pointed out that the Turkish Constitutional Court is now a dysfunctional legal channel. The committee argued that in Alakuş’s case, the Turkish government did not show any evidence that an individual complaint to challenge the detention before the Constitutional Court would have been effective, in practice. 

Likewise, former justice minister Sadullah Ergin said on November 2 that the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) might cancel the standing of Turkey’s Constitutional Court, which faces a barrage of individual applications, as a domestic remedy if the court does not issue rulings in line with the ECtHR.

Dr. Gökhan Güneş, a legal expert, on Sunday commented on the development in a series of tweets, saying that the committee’s decision, which directly concerns current proceedings in Turkey, was “historic.”

Hasan Dursun, a former prosecutor, stated on a YouTube program hosted by the Belgian-based TR724 news website that the UN committee had made several decisions in favor of defendants affiliated with the Gülen movement regarding arbitrary detentions and arrests in the past. “However, in that case, the committee examined the evidence for the first time,” he added.

According to Dursun, Turkey must implement the decisions of the UN committee in accordance with the international agreements and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights that Turkey committed to complying with as well as the decisions of the ECtHR.

ShareTweet
Previous Post

IRGC Quds Force dead drop, meeting venue in Turkey was reactivated

Next Post

Turkish interior minister claims ‘the country called Colombia’ plotted against Turkey over drug trafficking

Levent Kenez

Levent Kenez

[email protected]

Next Post
Turkish interior minister claims ‘the country called Colombia’ plotted against Turkey over drug trafficking

Turkish interior minister claims 'the country called Colombia' plotted against Turkey over drug trafficking

Turkish intelligence knew of ISIS safe houses before Reina attack, yet took no action

Turkish intelligence knew of ISIS safe houses before Reina attack, yet took no action

June 18, 2025
Kazakh medical student’s life upended by Turkish intelligence over false allegations

Kazakh medical student’s life upended by Turkish intelligence over false allegations

June 16, 2025
Turkey’s aggressive spying activities on German soil continue, secret document reveals

Germany accuses Turkey of endangering public security, conducting covert operations targeting dissidents

June 13, 2025
Turkish spies who tortured victim kidnapped from Kosovo protected by judiciary

Turkish spies who tortured victim kidnapped from Kosovo protected by judiciary

June 12, 2025
Turkish spy agency MIT disrupts Christian lives amid false allegations

Turkish spy agency MIT disrupts Christian lives amid false allegations

June 11, 2025
Ankara cautious after Israel detains Turks on Gaza aid ship, avoids escalation with ‘secret’ trade partner

Ankara cautious after Israel detains Turks on Gaza aid ship, avoids escalation with ‘secret’ trade partner

June 10, 2025
Espionage trial uncovers MIT surveillance of foreign diplomats in Turkey

Espionage trial uncovers MIT surveillance of foreign diplomats in Turkey

June 9, 2025
Ankara accuses  West of prolonging Ukrainian-Russian war

Ankara accuses West of prolonging Ukrainian-Russian war

June 9, 2025
Turkey’s state broadcaster TRT may have violated US foreign agent law

Turkey’s state broadcaster TRT may have violated US foreign agent law

June 5, 2025
Turkey and Finland sign defense industry cooperation deal amid rising Russian threats

Turkey and Finland sign defense industry cooperation deal amid rising Russian threats

June 4, 2025

Nordic Monitor

Nordic Monitor is a news web site and tracking site that is run by the Stockholm-based Nordic Research and Monitoring Network. It covers religious, ideological and ethnic extremist movements and radical groups, with a special focus on Turkey.

Tags

al-Qaeda Andrei Karlov China coup Cyprus Diyanet Egypt espionage Germany Greece Gülen Movement Hakan Fidan Hamas Hulusi Akar Ibrahim Kalın IHH Iran IRGC Quds Force ISIL ISIS Isis al-qaida Israel Libya Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu Milli İstihbarat Teşkilatı MIT Muslim Brotherhood NATO President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan Profiling Qatar Recep Tayyip Erdoğan Russia SADAT spying Spying Activities Suleyman Soylu Sweden Syria Torture Turkey Turkish Intelligence Agency Turkish intelligence agency MIT Ukraine United States

Recent News

Turkish intelligence knew of ISIS safe houses before Reina attack, yet took no action

Turkish intelligence knew of ISIS safe houses before Reina attack, yet took no action

June 18, 2025
Kazakh medical student’s life upended by Turkish intelligence over false allegations

Kazakh medical student’s life upended by Turkish intelligence over false allegations

June 16, 2025
Turkey’s aggressive spying activities on German soil continue, secret document reveals

Germany accuses Turkey of endangering public security, conducting covert operations targeting dissidents

June 13, 2025

Copyright © Nordic Research and Monitoring Network All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
    • Give us a tip!
  • About Us

Copyright © Nordic Research and Monitoring Network All rights reserved.