Friday, September 22, 2023
Nordic Monitor
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
    • Give us a tip!
  • About Us
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
    • Give us a tip!
  • About Us
No Result
View All Result
Nordic Monitor
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
  • About Us

Spying by Turkish diplomats triggers criminal investigations into children, spouses of critics

May 8, 2021
in EditorsPick, Foreign Policy, Intelligence
A A
Turkish embassies spied on critics in 92 countries, a new document reveals

Turkish Foreign Ministry building in Ankara.

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Nordic Monitor

 

Intelligence reports created by Turkish diplomatic missions as part of a large-scale spying campaign on critics and opponents of the Turkish government living outside Turkey have been used in criminal cases in which they, their spouses and even their children were prosecuted in absentia, government documents have revealed.

According to documents obtained by Nordic Monitor, a public prosecutor launched criminal investigations into five on dubious charges after they were profiled by Turkish diplomats who sent their names to the authorities in Turkey. The investigations show the prosecutor also ordered probes into the spouses and children of the people who were spied on abroad.

A document dated April 22, 2019 and signed by public prosecutor Birol Tufan highlights the fact that criminal investigations have been launched into innocent people who were listed in espionage files dispatched by Turkish diplomats without any concrete evidence of wrongdoing. As seen in several cases, Tufan first opened an investigation into Turkish nationals living abroad, then ordered the Ankara Police Department to provide further information on critics who were accused of links to the Gülen movement, a civic group that is highly critical of the authoritarian government of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.

However, the public prosecutor has the duty to conduct an investigation in order to decide whether it is necessary to prosecute and to ascertain if there are “factual findings that indicate a crime has been committed” in accordance with Article 160/1 of the Code on Criminal Procedure (CMK). None of the procedural safeguards were observed in prosecuting Erdoğan critics, while due process and fair trial protections have effectively been suspended in the Turkish judicial system.

The document laid bare how criminal investigations, prosecutions and trials were conducted in Turkey. It confirms that the Turkish judicial system is no longer impartial, credible or independent as indicated by several landmark decisions issued by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in favor of government critics.

According to the document conveyed by the Ankara Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office to the Ankara Police Department, prosecutor Tufan asked for information on the legal activities of critics such as depositing funds in the Bank Asya, volunteering at Gülen-affiliated organizations, working for companies linked to the movement, sharing social media messages in support of movement activities, sending their children to the country’s best-performing schools run by the Gülen movement and using a mobile messaging app called ByLock. The schools, bank, companies and other organizations were licensed and duly authorized by the government and regularly monitored and audited by the relevant government agencies.

Working for schools, foundations and companies established by businesspeople who were seen as close to the Gülen movement and sending children to schools run by the movement were considered acts of terrorism by the prosecutor. Moreover, Tufan flagged people as criminals because they had deposits at Bank Asya, once the largest Islamic lender in Turkey and one of its biggest private banks until it was unlawfully seized by the government in May 2015. In the document sent to the police, downloading ByLock, once a publicly available smart phone messaging application, was also defined as an act terrorism. Tufan also pursued investigations into family members, seeking to determine if they were members of associations and foundations affiliated with the Gülen movement, the details of their overseas trips and if they had cancelled their cable TV subscriptions to protest the government’s removal of critical TV networks from the lineup.

 

Two-page document confirming that Turkish diplomats triggered criminal prosecutions in Turkey. ID numbers in the document have been redacted by Nordic Monitor.

 

Turkish_diplomat_spying1

 

Turkish_diplomat_spying2

 

 

Over half a million people affiliated with the Gülen movement in Turkey have been put in detention facilities in the last three years alone on similar charges. Based on profiling lists, people were arrested, investigated and even prosecuted. Their assets were seized, and family members and relatives were also the subject of criminal charges. The critics identified in this specific case are listed as Gülsüm Emirdağ, Şerafettin Küççükoğlu, Orhan İnandi, Osman Karakuş and Süleyman Şentürk.

The investigation conducted by Tufan followed a pattern seen in other cases. In addition to the counterterrorism unit of the police department, he also forwarded the list to the Financial Crimes Investigation Board (MASAK) on February 2, 2019 for further action against the Turkish nationals who were profiled abroad by Turkish embassies and consulates. Tufan urged MASAK to investigate these people, their assets, companies and legitimate transactions on criminal pretexts. The documents indicated that the prosecutor profiled the spouses and family members including children and relatives of the critics in a guilt-by-association fallacy.

 

Prosecutor Birol Tufan. He used to be a small-town lawyer in the city of Alaplı in Zonguldak province until he was tapped by the Erdoğan government to serve as the regime’s prosecutor in 2014.

Nordic Monitor previously published a report disclosing the scope and extent of major spying activity conducted by Turkish diplomatic missions. The new documents revealed that such activity still continues and in fact results in serious consequences in Turkish judicial system. In addition to the arbitrary punishments in Turkey, people who were listed in these documents were also targeted by a campaign of intimidation and harassment and denied consular services abroad.

It is clear that Turkish diplomatic missions violate the domestic laws of receiving states and the principles of international law by conducting unlawful information-gathering campaigns and sweeping intelligence operations. Erdoğan’s envoys enjoyed the privileges and immunities described in the international conventions, while they systematically spied on critics of the President, collected information on Turks living abroad and transmitted it to headquarters.

The immunities and privileges of diplomats and consular staff are governed by international conventions. However, diplomats enjoying the privileges and immunities described in the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations are under a duty to respect the laws and regulations of the receiving state and to avoid interfering in its internal affairs as detailed in Article 41. Similarly, consular staff are granted limited privileges and immunities by the Vienna Convention on Consular Affairs, but the host state authorities can start investigations and prosecute any of the personnel if they perpetrate crimes inside or outside the consulate premises according to Article 43 of the convention.

 

Official document sent to MASAK. ID numbers in the document have been redacted by Nordic Monitor.

 

Birol_Tufan_Masak_redacted
ShareTweet
Previous Post

Prominent Muslim professor indicted for criticizing Diyanet, Turkey’s religious arm

Next Post

Turkish Airlines accused of violating security, immigration and labor laws abroad

Nordic Monitor

Nordic Monitor

[email protected]

Next Post
Turkish Airlines accused of violating security, immigration and labor laws abroad

Turkish Airlines accused of violating security, immigration and labor laws abroad

Please login to join discussion
Erdoğan urges US gov’t to lift defense industry sanctions despite lack of concrete steps toward Sweden’s NATO membership

Erdoğan urges US gov’t to lift defense industry sanctions despite lack of concrete steps toward Sweden’s NATO membership

September 22, 2023

The release of ISIS suspects gaining momentum in Turkey, new figures reveal

September 21, 2023
Document confirms diplomats spied on Erdoğan critic abducted by Turkish intelligence in Tajikistan

Document confirms diplomats spied on Erdoğan critic abducted by Turkish intelligence in Tajikistan

September 20, 2023
Turkey shifts focus to alternative projects as new US-backed trade corridor bypasses it for Greece

Turkey shifts focus to alternative projects as new US-backed trade corridor bypasses it for Greece

September 19, 2023
President Erdogan recruited antisemitic Turkish cleric indicted on sex trafficking charges

President Erdogan recruited antisemitic Turkish cleric indicted on sex trafficking charges

September 18, 2023
Mafia leader exposes looting of Erdogan critics’ houses

Mafia leader exposes looting of Erdogan critics’ houses

September 15, 2023
Extremist Turkish cop who led torture sessions in Ankara rewarded by Erdogan government

Extremist Turkish cop who led torture sessions in Ankara rewarded by Erdogan government

September 13, 2023
Mozambique emerges as a potential new buyer of Turkish drones

Mozambique emerges as a potential new buyer of Turkish drones

September 12, 2023
Turkey’s far right leader has long been an operative of Turkey’s ‘deep state’

Turkey’s far right leader has long been an operative of Turkey’s ‘deep state’

September 11, 2023
US Muslim Brotherhood leader calls Erdoğan’s re-election a ‘victory for the Muslim world’

US Muslim Brotherhood leader calls Erdoğan’s re-election a ‘victory for the Muslim world’

September 11, 2023

Nordic Monitor

Nordic Monitor is a news web site and tracking site that is run by the Stockholm-based Nordic Research and Monitoring Network. It covers religious, ideological and ethnic extremist movements and radical groups, with a special focus on Turkey.

Tags

al-Qaeda Andrei Karlov Andrei Karlov China coup Cyprus Diyanet Egypt espionage Germany Greece Gülen Movement Hakan Fidan Hulusi Akar Iran IRGC Quds Force ISIL ISIS Isis al-qaida Israel Libya Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu MIT Muslim Brotherhood NATO President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan Profiling Qatar Recep Tayyip Erdoğan Russia SADAT Saudi Arabia spying Spying Activities Suleyman Soylu Sweden Syria Torture Turkey Turkish Intelligence Agency Turkish intelligence agency MIT UID Ukraine United States Yasin al-Qadi

Recent News

Erdoğan urges US gov’t to lift defense industry sanctions despite lack of concrete steps toward Sweden’s NATO membership

Erdoğan urges US gov’t to lift defense industry sanctions despite lack of concrete steps toward Sweden’s NATO membership

September 22, 2023

The release of ISIS suspects gaining momentum in Turkey, new figures reveal

September 21, 2023
Document confirms diplomats spied on Erdoğan critic abducted by Turkish intelligence in Tajikistan

Document confirms diplomats spied on Erdoğan critic abducted by Turkish intelligence in Tajikistan

September 20, 2023

Copyright © Nordic Research and Monitoring Network All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Extremism
  • Military
  • Terrorism and Crime
  • Intelligence
  • Foreign Policy
  • Contact Us
    • Give us a tip!
  • About Us

Copyright © Nordic Research and Monitoring Network All rights reserved.